Study | Country Study period Study design |
Data source | Exposure definition | Non-exposure definition | Exposition period | Sample size (exposed/unexposed) Or (case / control) |
Remarks | Risk of bias |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Al-Otaibi 2019 |
Kuwait 2004 - 2017 retrospective cohort |
The Hamed Alessa Organ Transplant Center of Kuwait | Pregnant women maintained on tacrolimus-based regimen (all patients also maintained on steroids plus azathioprine). |
exposed to other treatment, sick
Pregnant women maintained on cyclosporin-based regimen (all patients also maintained on steroids plus azathioprine). |
throughout pregnancy | 33 / 49 | ||
All pregnancy data were collected from medical records maintained by the institution. | ||||||||
Alvaro 2013 |
Spain 1986 - 2011 retrospective cohort |
Hospital Universitario 12 de Octubre Surgery. | Pregnant women with orthotopic liver transplantation using tacrolimus during pregnancy. |
exposed to other treatment, sick
Pregnant women with orthotopic liver transplantation using cyclosporine during pregnancy. |
throughout pregnancy | 15 / 5 | No mention of mycophenomate mofetil. | |
Examination of the records of all women recipients of reproductive age who underwent transplantation from 1986 to 2011. | ||||||||
Ichinose 2018 |
Japan 2008 - 2016 retrospective cohort |
Nagasaki University Hospital, National Hospital Organization (NHO) Nagasaki Medical Center, and Japan Community Healthcare Organization (JCHO) Isahaya General Hospital. | Mothers with systemic lupus erythematosus treated with tacrolimus during the pregnancy. |
unexposed, sick
Mothers with systemic lupus erythematosus never treated with tacrolimus during pregnancy. |
during pregnancy (anytime or not specified) | 15 / 39 | The patients for whom tacrolimus treatment was terminated during a pregnancy were excluded. | |
Patients’ medical records were reviewed retrospectively including clinical and laboratory information. | ||||||||
Kim 2015 |
Seoul, Korea 1991 - 2012 prospective cohort |
Asan Medical Center and Seoul National University Hospital | Deliveries given tacrolimus-based immunosuppressants mostly combined with azathioprine and/or steroids (prednisolone or methylprednisolone). |
exposed to other treatment, sick
Deliveries given cyclosporine-based immunosuppressants mostly combined with azathioprine and/or steroids (prednisolone or methylprednisolone). |
throughout pregnancy | 28 / 60 | None of the pregnancies were exposed to mycophenolic acid. | |
Medical records. Whole blood trough drug concentrations of CNI were examined at eight consecutive time points: from 12 months before delivery to 12 months after. | ||||||||
Perales-Puchalt 2012 |
Valencia, Spain 1995 - 2009 retrospective cohort |
Hospital Universitario La Fe | Immunosuppressive drugs used was Tacrolimus. All patients used Prednisone as a co-adjuvant therapy. The treatment protocol of the patients remained unchanged during the study period. |
exposed to other treatment, sick
Immunosuppressive drugs used were Cyclosporine-A and four had a combination with Azathioprine. All patients used Prednisone as a co-adjuvant therapy. The treatment protocol of the patients remained unchanged during the study period. |
throughout pregnancy | 9 / 11 | Cyclosporine-A (CsA) and Azathioprine (AZA) groups could not be add because four pregnancies had a combination of CsA and AZA. Combinations are detailed and no mycophenolate mofetil involved. | |
Patient information was gathered for clinical records, used to obtain the information for the study in a retrospective manner. The treatment protocol of the patients remained unchanged during the study period. | ||||||||
Thompson 2003 |
England 1976 - 2001 retrospective cohort |
Centre for Nephrology and Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, Royal Free and University College School of Medicine, London. | Pregnant transplanted patients under tacrolimus, prednisolone and azathioprine. |
exposed to other treatment, sick
Pregnant transplanted patients under prednisolone, azathioprine -based regimens, with or without cyclosporine. |
throughout pregnancy | 4 / 23 | No mycophenolate mofetil. | |
Review of the case notes detailed doses of immunosuppression and dose changes made during pregnancy, and other medications. | ||||||||
Wielgos 2012 |
Poland 2005 - 2010 retrospective cohort |
A retrospective, single-center study conducted in the Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Medical University of Warsaw. | Pregnant women who underwent renal or liver transplantation treated with tacrolimus-based regimen (alone or with prednisolone and/or azathioprine). |
exposed to other treatment, sick
Pregnant women who underwent renal or liver transplantation treated with cyclosporine-based regimen (alone or with prednisolone and/or azathioprine).. |
throughout pregnancy | 21 / 9 | Data of patients treated with tacrolimus who underwent both renal and liver transplantation were added. None of women were treated with mycophenolate mofetil nor sirolimus during the time of pregnancy. | |
Complete data was obtained for doses and regimens of immunosuppressive medication and maternal/fetal outcomes (Not otherwise specified). |
Study | Country Study period Study design |
Data source | Case | Control | Exposition | Exposition period | Sample size (exposed/unexposed) Or (case / control) |
Remarks | Risk of bias |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Sugawara 2019 |
Japan 2007 - 2016 nested case control |
Hokkaido University Hospital in Hokkaido, Japan | Pregnant women with any maternal and/or fetal complications. | Pregnant women without any maternal and/or fetal complications. | Clinical characteristics including history of rheumatic diseases treatment were recorded from medical records. | during pregnancy (anytime or not specified) | 34 / 23 | Maternal adverse events: 34 cases and 23 controls. Fetal adverse events: 27 cases and 30 controls. Authors made some comparison with general obstetric population in Japan (GOP), but there is no distinction between treatments (results not reported here). | |
Data on pregnancy outcomes and maternal complications were collected (Not other specified). |
Risk of bias: : NA; : low; : moderate; : serious; : critical; : unclear;